Your daughter Hannah died 15 years ago, when she was seven
months old. It doesn’t take much to bring you back here: the photo of that
baby, Avery, online with her bucket list*, because that’s how Hannah looked,
and so you don’t read Avery’s bucket list because—well, for a lot of reasons:
1) you didn’t make a bucket list for Hannah, 2) you had a mental list of all
the things Hannah would not get to do, and that seems kind of negative now, 3)
you should have done more, 4) Did you do enough? 5) you don’t remember those
days, 6) you remember those days too well, 7) seeing Avery’s photo makes your
sternum hurt.
You don’t know exactly why you can’t read about other SMA
babies, because you should do it. And you should email the parents and say that
SMA sucks but there is always love and some research being done. But it would
take a miracle for the research to bear fruit in time. And that is so negative.
You’ve always been a little negative, especially about SMA. Thankfully, often
you are proven wrong. So you could also say some kids are living longer with
SMA-Type I, thanks to pharmaceutical trials and new technology. And that’s
progress. That's hope.
But even though you wanted Hannah to live longer: when she
died, it was time. Even though you wanted her back the next day: it was still
time. She hurt. She couldn’t breathe. She could only blink. She couldn’t close
her mouth or point her finger or move anything at all on her body. These are
things you know.
And you had another girl after Hannah died, one who was born
without SMA (though she may be a carrier) and who last month turned 14. Megan
talks back and leaves her clothes all over the floor and is as tall as you now. She makes you laugh. And when she was a baby, you just sat and played with her and held her and did
whatever she wanted, for the most part, and that probably wasn’t normal or even
healthy for her. And maybe that’s why her room is so messy and she often loses her
pencil bag.
And one day, arguing over religion with the 14-year-old,
Megan, you said that if Hannah hadn’t died, she and Megan would’ve been raised
Catholic because their dad was Catholic and you all went to the Catholic Church.
And Megan said, “If Hannah hadn’t died, I wouldn’t have been born.” And maybe
she’s right, and maybe she’s not. And you think about that some more. You can’t
imagine not having had both of them. What if you had to choose? What if Megan
was right: that if Hannah had lived you’d never have had Megan? You couldn’t
bear it. So you’ll take Hannah’s short life and Megan’s birth and good health. You’ll
take them both as they are.
You know that if Hannah hadn’t died, maybe your marriage wouldn’t
have ended when it did, but it most likely would have ended anyway. You read
later that the death of a child doesn’t mean the end of your marriage unless
the dam is already cracked. From all these years away, you look back and see
the water trickling long before Hannah. And that’s a relief, because you never
wanted Hannah’s legacy to be divorce. The marriage gave you two daughters.
And then you met a man who has good laugh lines and a gift
for growing vegetables in the backyard, things you longed for without even
knowing it. Now you have homegrown lettuce, four chairs around the kitchen
table, and a baby daughter, Natalie (you longed for her too, yes you did,
without knowing it).
And if you rewrote your life, none of this could be edited
out.
You know what Hannah would have looked like because sometimes
you imagine her there beside you in the kitchen—she is there—thick-haired and
solid, calm. And sometimes you close your eyes and kiss her cheek that is not
physically there but really is somehow there, or you hold her hand in the car
for a second. In this unspoken way, you’ve seen her grow up.
You’ve never dreamed about Hannah—not in the way that,
during the most difficult times in your life, your grandmother has visited you
in dreams because she’s your grandmother and you needed her badly, so she came.
You don’t want Hannah feeling bound to your grief, like visits are “necessary.”
You know you can’t rely on your child to save you emotionally. And so you
don’t. Still, she’s with you sometimes, you know.
![]() |
| Hannah Morgan Marshall, 10/14/96-5/23/97 |
You remember the months and the years after that, the same way
you remember childbirth: in hazy scenes, vignettes. Life continued, and after a
period of years (How many was it?) you seemed kind of normal, you hoped, but
you were changed. And that was another gift Hannah gave you: She made you not
normal anymore, and you embrace that, the same way you hold Natalie and hug Megan,
less lately since she’s getting so teenaged and tall, and you make a mental
note right now to do that more: to hug that girl more. Because you can.
*Avery Lynn Canahuati died April 30.






